I mentioned in the previous post that Jenna Burke is no Carrie Bradshaw. I can say that based on the quality of her blog and her actions on the Bachelor.
So that begs the question–how would Carrie Bradshaw behave on the Bachelor? There are two possibilities that I see. One scenario would be that she would get emotional like Jenna and be a trainwreck just like Jenna. Like the dating/relatonship blogger who fails miserably when put on the spot. But I think Carrie would have handled it with more humor and there would have been some upside. There didn’t seem to be an upside with Jenna.
Or, Carrie would have excelled on the show, either to be eliminated right at the end or to be proposed to, only to decline. Carrie, after all, is complicated. But she would have handled the show with humor, grace, vulnerability, but in the end she would have acted like the journalism professional.
So, that begs the question–how would the other characters have fared on the show?
Well, Miranda probably wouldn’t have been chosen. Sorry hon, but you were just not sexy enough.
Samantha wouldn’t have made it very far either. She is sexy and attractive, but she would not have been able to make the emotional connection, and she would have pissed the other women off.
Charlotte is the one person who could have pulled it off. She has just enough of the good looks, feminine wiles, and good strategy to know when to hold them and when to fold them.
It would have made a good episode of SATC.